Findings:

• Who the heck wants to look like an old lady? Pick me, pick me!
• it doesn't matter who I was, all that matters is who I am
• I remember when it was me who made her toilet flush
• i saw the ugliest thing in the world and thought it was neat-o
• I met a girl in the garden who was doomed to die the next day.
• I Was Looking at the Ceiling And Then I Saw the Sky
• She was thinking of a boy in California who had a couch and a job
• The Man Who Was (user)
• Able was I, ere I saw Elba
• It was men who made breasts into a secret.
• Who Was the Wine Girl?
• Jones saw forest, saw nothing for it, was a little telephone apology
• Seriously, though, who the hell did I think I was going to become?
• Tribute to the Man Who Never Was (document)
• Of the Birth of Volsung, the Son of Rerir, who was the Son of Sigi
• I remember when it was me who made her skin flush
• The first time I saw him was I emit tsal ehT
• I Fell In Love With A Girl Who Was Already Gone.
• He was the kind of man who shacked up for shelter
• all I ever learned from love was how to shoot at someone who outdrew you
• I came, I saw and was undone
• Who's the finest lady in all of Disney? (e2poll)
• There was a young lady of Riga
• The Man Who Saw the Flood
• The Story of the Vizier Who Was Punished
• Fast-talking career gal who thought she was one of the boys
• The other day I saw a gas station called Space Age! I was not fooled!
• A dose of mystery slipped into her cocktail while she was in the ladies' room
• To a girl who thought she was moving away
• The Tale of a Youth who set out to learn what Fear was
• The Princess who was Hidden Underground
• The boy who was picked last in gym class
• Who shouted with glee when the colour blue was born?
• The Man Who Was Thursday
• Of Gods and Men: Who Was This Man Called the Christ?
• The Story of the Envious Man and of Him Who Was Envied
• A cute lady mechanic who fixed his engine and damn near broke his heart
• There was a man who lived a life of fire
• I was the man who never lied. I never lied until today.
• A Woman Who Never Was
• everyone who ever told me i was pretty was lying.
• Existentialism is that girlfriend who cheated on you. Postmodernism is who she was with.
• I remember when it was me who made you want to take over the world and enslave humanity
• The old lady who lived in a bottle
• There was an old lady
• To a Young Lady Who Sent Me a Laurel Crown
• I Know an Old Lady Who Swallowed a Fly
• Our Lady Peace
• Church Lady
• Lunch Lady Doris
• First Lady
• Lady
• proper ladies
• Lady Audley's Secret
• A lady in public and a whore in the bedroom
• Lady Godiva
• Lady Sings The Blues
• Lady and the Tramp
• The Seven Lady Godivas
• Lady Paige
• Lords and Ladies
• The Lady Eve
• There was a young lady named Wilde
• cleaning lady
• Ladies' eardrops
• Lady's bower
• Lady's comb
• Lady's cushion
• Lady's finger
• Lady's garters
• Lady's hair
• Lady's laces
• Lady's looking-glass
• Lady's mantle
• Lady's seal
• Lady's slipper
• Lady's smock
• I'm starting to think the secret is to NOT be rich and prosperous. To be 'unsuccessful' (depending on who you ask)
• The Lady of Shalott
• A young lady named Bright
• ladies' man
• Lady Bracknell
• Lady Master
• Death Of A Ladies' Man
• Ladies' Sewing Circle and Terrorist Society
• Lady Cottington's Pressed Fairy Book
• rubber lady
• Lady Midnight (user)
• Lady Lindy
• Lady Day
• Old Lady
• Lady Alia Atreides
• ladies of everything
• The Lady's Not for Burning
• Edinburgh University Ladies Rugby Football Club
• Little Old Chinese Ladies
• helping old ladies cross the street
• Squire Petrick's Lady
• Electric Lady Studios
• My Fair Lady
• The Spanish Lady
• The Lady
• The Story of the Three Calenders, Sons of Kings, and of Five Ladies of Bagdad
• Our Lady of Mount Carmel
• Sniffy-nosed telephone lady
• I'm a crazy old lady all hopped-up on Estrogen pills
• I'm a crazy old lady whose ex-husband bought himself a Soloflex for my birthday
• Lady Gregory
• Lady Louse
• Call me a lady and I will growl at you
• Scottish Universities Ladies Rugby Championship
• an old lady's three wishes
• Gorgeous Ladies of Wrestling
• Portrait of a Lady
• The Lady, or the Tiger?
• Old lady Henry
• Book of the City of Ladies
• I recommend driving like an Old Lady
• One Man Army
• The Craziest Lady to Ever Grace a Burger King Drive-Thru
• Lady Izumi
• I'm trying to see little old ladies as versions of my mom; it helps me be a better person
• Mourning Lady Kaga
• Ladies and gentlemen
• Spanish Ladies
• The Ultimate ladies' man secrets
• Lady Ise
• The New Lady
• The Lady Mechanic's Total Car Care for the Clueless
• everyone knows Shirley, the bread lady
• Never underestimate Old Ladies
• Hamburger Lady
• Another Dark Lady
• The old lady with the cats
• Martha Stewart Lady
• An Epithalamion, or Marriage Song on the Lady Elizabeth and Count Palatine
• dragon lady
• Rose Lady
• Lady Warrior
• bag lady
• The Fat Lady Sings
• backrub for a lady
• Two old ladies by the bus stop
• Lady Jane Grey
• The Ladies Man
• the cat lady
• White Lady
• The Iron Lady
• There were three young ladies of Birmingham
• The lady of situations
• Mommy, this lady's wearing Skechers!
• A lady in a church
• Lady Marmalade
• There once was a young lady named Gloria
• There was a young lady named Puck
• Lady Astor
• Song of a Young Lady to her Ancient Lover
• The Lunch Lady
• Lady In Red
• To a Fat Lady Seen from the Train
• The Lady with the Stopwatch
• Nine Inch Will Please a Lady
• Voodoo Lady
• Drunk Lady meets Smarmy Guy
• Sophisticated Lady
• Our Lady of Lourdes (user)
• Ladies From Hell
• In Praise of My Lady
• Lady Mary Wroth

If you Log in you could create a "Who Was That Lady I Saw You With?" node. If you don't already have an account, you can register here.