Please note that this list is probably not complete but these are all the players I could find who subscribe to the Hebraic faith along with their years of service.

• Sandy Koufax (1955-66)
• Hank Greenberg (1930-47)
• Ron Blomberg (1969-78)
• Ross Baumgarten (1978-82)
• Steve Rosenberg (1988-91)
• Steve Hertz (1964)
• Moe Berg (1923-39)
• Moe Solomon (1923) Nickname: The Rabbi of Swat
• Mike Epstein (1966-74) Nickname: Superjew
• Andy Cohen (1926-29)
• Ken Holtzman (1965-79)
• Al Schacht (1919-21)
• Gabe Kapler (1998-present)
• Mike Lieberthal (1994-2007)
• Rod Carew (converted) (1967-85)
• Elliott Maddox (converted) (1970-80)
• Art Shamsky (1965-72)
• Shawn Green (1993-2007)
• Steve Stone (1971-81) Gave up Duane Kuiper's only home run
• Lipman "Lip" Pike (1866-77)
• Ryan Braun (2007-present)