What this makes me think of first is another phrase/meme: Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles.

I own Teenage Ninja Mutant Turtles #1 and #2. I bought them when they first came out, in a comic book store. I bought them because the title made me laugh: making fun of all of the popular trends in comic books.

They were all male, of course. Those turtles. I was collecting comic books, though I had little money, rare access to comic stores, and no support. I was rejecting the girl princess meme and was way more interested in the hero meme. Though not Superman: boring, one dimensional, too powerful, and how would he and Lois reproduce anyhow? Sex would presumably kill her. Ok, they could go do it in the Krypton bottle, with his powers negated. But then she'd have to stay there for the pregnancy, because hey, otherwise the superfetus would kick its way out of her womb.

No, I liked the angst of Spiderman. He still had all sorts of problems, many of them his own fault. Because he couldn't see the consequences of his early actions. Power and responsibility.

And that brings us to this article: https://www.salon.com/2014/07/15/im_sorry_for_coining_the_phrase_manic_pixie_dream_girl/

I think of Winnie-the-Pooh. Every character is male except for Kanga, the mother. I think of The Hobbit. Again, a dearth of women. There are so many movies and books where there is a token girl or princess or girlfriend. As if women do not exist, as if we are not everywhere. I liked Spiderman as a preteen because he loves his aunt, misses his uncle and parents, has both male and female friends. The Fantastic Four only has one female and the villains are male too. Superman has a girlfriend or occasionally women rivals for his affection, but the villains... male. Male sidekick, male boss, male male male male. Star Wars, Star Trek.... how about an older woman villain? Who is not a witch or a stepmother, just your usual crazy power mad I want to rule the world or I want to destroy everyone....

I wonder if that is too frightening to imagine. Is our culture so caught up with the male hero and yet the unconscious knows that women endure daily discrimination. If women were to get angry, if women were to stand together, if enough women, say 150 or more, band together to say that in fact this physician has been abusing women for over 20 years, then what would happen?

How about a comic with a women, acting the manic pixie dream girl, and underneath that is the volcano of pain and grief and years of abuse?

Banshes: Manic Pixie Dream Girl

for reQuest 2018

The Manic Pixie Dream Girl is a character type trope that's a staple of saccharine sub-par romantic comedies and harem anime, though it pops up all over the place in various forms.

Tell me if you've heard it before:

There's this guy. Maybe he's an introvert, a homebody who doesn't like going out. Maybe he's unlucky in life and love both. Maybe he's broody. Maybe he's reserved. Maybe he's a workaholic who can't stand being away from the office. Maybe he's a widower who never got over losing his first love. It all boils down to the same thing: the dude isn't really living. At least, not in a way the target audience would find fulfilling.

But then he runs into someone. Maybe they meet cute and literally bump into each other. Maybe he's decided to change his life and they run across each other at whatever dance club or pottery class he's decided to attend. Maybe he gets robbed. Maybe they're at school and she's the new foreign exchange student.

Whatever the case, the male protagonist will come across a female character who is quirky, but in a way that's endearing rather than alienating. She's happy and vibrant and creative, and will usually have a childish naivete about the world. In her purest form, she sees things through rose colored glasses, and it seems that within the first ten minutes of meeting the protagonist, she will dedicate her life to getting him to see the world that way too, dragging him along on her adventures and breaking him out of his rut. There might be some hint of her own story, but if there is, it's glossed over or unimportant to the main plot. The real issue that the writers want to address is thus: boring guy needs a peppy emotional cheerleader girlfriend to help him appreciate life and its wonders.

There is also the Magical Girlfriend variant where the girl in question is actually an angel or robot or genie or mermaid or some sort of supernatural/nonhuman entity.

Depending on the level of cynicism on the part of the writers, the manic pixie dream trope can be deconstructed to show how that level of immaturity and impulsiveness is actually kinda bad in real life. That's where you start getting more horrific examples that involve men getting stalked by emotionally unstable women, or finding out that the chirpy, quirky girl is actually dealing with mental instability/depression and needs to be rescued after all.

In more modern media, there is also the trend of genderflipping the roles and having an adventurous and childish guy character make a woman appreciate life and all its mysteries and wonder. This is related to, but not the same as, the other overused bad rom-com trope of a tough workaholic lady who says she wants to be independent, but actually needs a charming man to come into her life and teach her love.

Wikipedia has an entire list of proposed MPDGs

Temporary note: I knew I should've posted this yesterday.

She's quirky, bubbly, often childlike, and lives a seemingly carefree existence. Of course, she often has underlying psychological issues, but these do not concern us much. No, this collection of quirks in bohemian clothing exists solely for the male protagonist. He's living a dour or uninteresting life, and she enters it to inspire him and show him what he can become.

Having helped him find himself, she generally disappears.

Film critic Nathan Rabin first used the term in 2007 when reviewing Elizabethtown, as a descriptor for Kirsten Dunst's character Claire Colburn. Rabin noted she was part of a larger trope, the quirky girl who "exists solely in the fevered imaginations of sensitive writer-directors to teach broodingly soulful young men to embrace life and its infinite mysteries and adventures." He now regrets it. The term took on a life of its own, and got used in ways he now finds discomforting. Principally, however, it gets applied to quirky female characters from quirky or indie films, especially those from from around the turn of the millennium. Layla (Christina Ricci) from Buffalo '66 (1998), Penny Lane (Kate Hudson) from Almost Famous (2000), Sam (Natalie Portman) from Garden State (2004), and Anna Barnes-Leatherwood (Charlize Theron) A Million Ways to Die in the West (2014) would all qualify as Manic Pixie Dream Girls.

Other oft-cited examples prove more problematic. Summer Finn (Zooey Deschanel) from 500 Days of Summer, Clementine Kruczynski (Kate Winslet) from Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind, Ruby Sparks from Ruby Sparks, and Margo Roth Spiegelman (Cara Delevingne) from Paper Towns (2015) often make the list, but those films, with varying degrees of success, examine the trope and find it wanting. Ramona Flowers from Scott Pilgrim vs. the World has more than a little of the MPDG about her. She's far more developed in the original graphic novels, and the movie's ending, arguably, undercuts the trope. The movie's alternate ending, alternatively, reinforces it.1 The title character of the novel (and forthcoming film) Looking for Alaska might qualify. Audrey/Lulu (Melanie Griffith) from Something Wild (1986)? Possibly. Holly Golightly in Breakfast at Tiffany's? The Muses? The term now gets thrown around so liberally that any quirky female character who assists a male character or (more damaging) quirky female who draws breath now risks getting identified as a MPDG.

The character presents a number of problems, already highlighted by previous write-ups. Rabin himself notes the use of the term may even reinforce the kind of sexism his identification of the trope decried. By applying it broadly, critics may point out when a character is merely a male fantasy, but it may also lead viewers and readers to reduce more complex characters-- or, you know, actual human beings-- to male fantasies.

As with all character-related tropes, it presents the most trouble when it gets applied to actual human beings, who may aspire to be more than adjuncts to someone's personal development.

Men, of course, can also be presented as adjuncts to a lover's character development, and lists of Manic Pixie Dream Boys can now be found. The MPDB (or G) relates to the trope of the White Knight-- in its earlier, pre-internet meaning--: the perfect man who rides into some women's life to carry her off and set everything right.2

The Manic Pixie Dream Girl has inspired other people, including a handful of indie bands who have recorded songs by that name. A writer named Tom Leveen published a YA novel entitled manicpixiedreamgirl in 2014. Poet Olivia Gatwood created an excellent performance piece decrying the character. It seems the Manic Pixie Dream Girl will not disappear any time soon, either as character or term of discourse.

1. SPOILERS! Bryan Lee O'Malley had not yet finished the series when the movie went into production, so the filmmakers shot two endings. In the other one, He ends up with Knives Chau, and Ramona dutifully disappears.

2. "White Knight" took on a second meaning, the male who supports feminist and female-oriented causes only because he's trying to look caring and sensitive so he can get laid. Of course, since that usage gets most of its play online, where there is no chance of the male making the comment ever meeting the female he's supporting, it arguably now has the third meaning of convenient term of abuse to silence men who might actually support a feminist or female-oriented cause.

Log in or register to write something here or to contact authors.