fallacy: the forcing of a dichotomy onto an issue that is not binary, eliminating many options from consideration

If you're not with me, you're against me

The Illusion of Choice and a "Helpful" Lesson on Parenting

If you are trying to convince your children to go to bed, do not simply say, "Go to bed," nor ask, "Would you please go to bed now?" In your child's mind, this statement can be met with one of two chioces - to obey or to disobey. If instead you ask, "Would you like to go to bed at 8 or at 9?" you have limited the scope of choices down to two, while still making it appear as if you are now allowing more choices.

While this may seem so simplistic that only children could be thus duped, there are many other examples in adult life - Coke or Pepsi? Democrat or Republican? Communist or capitalist? Monetarism or Keynesianism? War or Peace?

There are many more choices outside of going to sleep at 8 or 9, but your kids don't have to know that   ;-)

Log in or registerto write something here or to contact authors.