Answer to old chestnut: water and wine:

There is the same amount of water in the wine as there is wine in the water.

To understand this, let X equal the volume of water in the wine and Y the volume of wine in the water. Since it is a closed system, we must have 1 gallon - Y wine in the wine and 1 gallon - X water in the water. However, the total volume in each container is still one gallon, since we removed a teaspoon and added a teaspoon to each container. So 1 gallon - Y + X = 1 gallon, so Y = X.

This type of analysis is at the heart of material and energy balances, the first distinctly chemical engineering course most chemical engineering students take. The calculation above is a material balance on one container, accounting for all the flows in and out of the container and the initial and final contents of the container.

Log in or registerto write something here or to contact authors.