Ghost in the Shell 2: Innocence
is a direct sequel to Mamaru Oshii
's Ghost in the Shell
. Like the original, it is a screen adaptation of the manga by Masamune Shirow
. It was released in the U.S. by Production I.G.
on Friday, September 17th, 2004
in 'select cities' - and since Cambridge, MA
was one of those, off I went with cash in my hot li'l hands.
The film clocks in at 99 minutes, which feels just about right. I'll offer some general impressions first, followed by some more detailed observations - so if at any point you think I'm telling you things you'd rather not know yet, stop reading and go see it. I'll wait. I'll try not to offer true spoilers, but one man's spoiler is another man's context, so YMMV. I do assume you've seen the first film, though.
As I mentioned, the film is a true sequel. The action takes place some time after the original film leaves off, and is mostly concerned with Agents Bateau and Togusa of Section 9. Their enigmatic Chief Aramaki makes appearances, as does their colleague Ishikawa. As we are told early on in the film through dialogue, The Major is listed as 'missing' on official records. Bateau is still apparently the only one who knows the whole story on her disappearance.
This movie follows the same sort of pattern as the first - there is a general plot, concerning a crime or series of crimes committed by a shadowy adversary. On top of that, there is a fairly deep philosophical question that is explored somewhat obsessively. The dialogue is rife with quotations from various writers and philosophers, ranging from Descartes to Confucious to Shakespeare and the Old Testament, with all manner of uncredited proverbs and others thrown in. The characters spend entire conversations just tossing quotes at each other. This makes the actual progress of the movie somewhat difficult to follow on the first sitting, especially if you are viewing the dialogue as subtitles (as I was). I still prefer subtitling to dubbing, however; the native (original) voice talent is noticeably superior to the English voice talent used for the dubbed versions of the first film.
The animation is fascinating. There is an enormous quantity of CGI used in the film, but very little of it is whole-scene; in most cases, the hand-drawn characters move through obsessively photorealistic CGI-rendered scenery, looking eerily out of place, almost like the Ghosts the title invokes. Their muted tones and simple shading differentiates them from their surroundings, which are sometimes so sharp-edged as to be almost painful (to wit: the convenience store). Vehicles are a mix; there are anonymous non-central cars which dart in and out of darkness and rain, but there are also the main characters' vehicles, which inexplicably have become almost fetishistic. Bateau drives what appears to be a replica of a 1950s Chevrolet, as near as I can tell. Ishikawa drives a Duesenberg J replica. Even Togusa's drab sedan is a classic car rather than the blandly ultramodern conveyances preferred by Section 9 in the original film and in the TV series. Besides being sometimes CGI and sometimes obviously hand-drawn, some of the cars sport mirrored surfaces, further confusing the world they zip through.
Around two-thirds of the way through the film, just as in the first, there is an 'intermission' of sorts which is devoted to pure eye-candy - an aerial and street-level tour of the 'northern frontier' region, a lawless extra-sovereign data haven which happens to be sporting a mammoth festival as our protagonists pass through. Gigantic puppets and false ships pass through classically anime streets lined with impossibly tall and somehow gothic skyscrapers, people observing from Gernsbackian balconies and skyways along the route as Blade Runner-esque displays on every flat surface trumpet not only the action on the floats but the latest pills and gadgets. The sensory overload is palpable, driving even the characters on screen underground to escape the clamor.
After this point, the philosophical angle of the plot picks up. Deliberate blurring of reality and hacked memories implanted directly into the 'e-brain' of various characters, confusion between people and robots ("gynoids") - all fairly familiar to any aficionado of the genre, but handled with care and reverence by Oshii and company. The film raises some questions that will stay with you after you leave - not about what happened, which is fairly well wrapped up, but about what didn't happen. Or, if you prefer, about what may or may not have happened. The games start there, and I suspect will only get worse until I can get my hands on a DVD copy and watch it enough times to be able to ignore the subtitling and pick up on the many important bits that Oshii likes to drop in around the periphery of the visual field.
None of this is to say the film stints on action. While there is less humor than in the first, perhaps, there is a goodly quantity of familiar combat sequences, well done and tightly choreographed, interspersed with the virtual combat of computer network intrusion that anyone who saw the first film will be familiar with. Bateau has certainly not lost his taste for obscenely large weaponry; Togusa still has his old-fashioned revolver (despite what the Major told him in the first movie) and is still 'mostly human.' Folks that have watched the TV series will perhaps feel more at home, as the plotline seems to feel more like an expanded episode of the series than a continuation of the first movie; however, when paired together, the two make a satisfying match.
The Major? Well, you'll have to see it. I did say it was about Bateau, after all.
Ghost in the Shell 2: Innocence
Director: Mamoru Oshii
Story: Masamune Shirow
) and Mamoru Oshii
Runtime: 99 mins
Released: 2004 (Japan, US)
Sound mix: DTS
/ Dolby EX 6.1
Languages: Japanese, Cantonese (English Subtitle)
Rating: PG-13 for violence
(Thanks to IMDB)
: Responses to dkogan
's points as raised below.
In general, the flow of GiTS2:I suffers from the fact that it is subtitled. I suspect but cannot prove that some (not all) of the ponderous nature of the dialog is due to the subtitling. One problem I didn't mention is that the subtitling detracts from the flow of the film (especially from the first viewing) due to the need to have one's view concentrated at the bottom of the screen for large portions of time.
First off, I've never seen Grave of the Fireflies or Jin-Roh, so I don't know if I fit into "Set A." I fairly despised the second two Matrix movies. I do enjoy the first GiTS movie. I will say this: This movie does, indeed, revisit the same issues that the first GiTS movie spent a great deal of time exploring. Namely, what makes humans human? There are slightly different angles here, though. The first movie asks us: at what point do modified humans retain or lose their humanity? The Major's pensive mien is informed by her obsession with this question - her concern with her own potential loss of her humanity. In this film, the torch has been passed to Bateau, who has even more data - he watched the Major transcend her human-built cyberbody entirely, and must wonder: if she survives, in the net, is she human, in some way? If so, does that make him more or less human?
The question is complicated by the problem of the gynoids. They are approaching the question from the other end - machines built to be more and more human, approaching self-awareness, with (as we learn) extreme measures taken. The young girls are not actually 'transferred' to the dolls, rather, they are copied (using a process called 'ghost dubbing' which debuted in the Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex series) (Note: randombit tells me the notion of ghost-dubbing girls into gynoids was introduced in the original print manga). Those copies are embedded in the dolls. The process is eventually destructive to the originals, but (as the ending shows us) the original human is at no time actually transferred to a gynoid. The question Bateau struggles with, then, is what is the degree of difference between himself and the gynoid - as he approaches mechanicity, and it approaches humanity?
The additional dimension that GiTS2:I offers is the study of the relationship between humans and the robots they create, something which the first film essentially ignored. The obvious relationships between humans and their sex-toy gynoids is not the only one under question; as dkogan notes, Togusa's daughter's doll is another example of the same type of relationship, as is the relationship between Bateau and his (cloned) basset hound. It's not supposed to be 'eerie' - it's supposed to make you think. At the end of the film, we see both main characters embracing their own 'smalls' - Togusa holding his daughter, Bateau holding his dog - and Togusa's daughter is holding her doll, the cycle continuing, as Bateau watches.
dkogan has some quite valid points about the film's pacing and styling, and of course some perfectly valid opinions about the same. The balance of contemplative vs. action-oriented storyline in an anime is a matter of personal preference, and this film definitely tends towards the former. If this is not to your liking, you will be disappointed. However, the questions that the film uses to anchor its story are no less valid or 'deep' for having been raised before. They are asked using a medium that Oshii and Masamune are comfortable with, and are expert with; this is why it's worth (IMHO) seeing. If you feel the need to see enormous weapons and cute dialog in (nearly) every scene, it's not for you. If you need to see the birdshit with every bird, nope, maybe it's not for you. But if you like to watch artists grapple with questions, even familiar ones, then I still recommend the film.