So, on Friday, in a
desparate attempt to avoid getting
shut down,
Napster announced they're going to implement
sophisticated technology to
block songs that
copyright holders have identified as
protected. This was supposed to happen this weekend, but it's nearly 3pm
Eastern Standard Time on
Sunday, and I'm still getting
hits on Napster when I type in
Metallica.
This begs numerous questions, and belies a fundamental flaw in Napster. The questions are:
This underscores the flaw that
Napster is dependent on
filenames (and to a lesser extent
id3 tags) to identify music. Basically, filtering filenames will probably slow people down for a few days. Also, being dependent on this
inconsistent nomenclature prevents Napster from doing cool, useful things like identifying multiple copies of a song, and
geographically prioritizing data, or
load balancing song requests by redoing
search order, and the like. I've always thought that
Napster is clumsy, and this whole thing just reiterates that. There's no way for Napster to really know what song is what, they're dependent on users not
lying.
I have a feeling this isn't going to stop the injunction.