One of the prime
differences of beliefs existing today among some Jew
s and some Christian
s vs. standard Muslim
argument is the story of Abraham sacrifice
toward his only son. Jews and Christians maintain it was Isaac to be sacrificed. Muslims retain it was Ishmael to be sacrificed. Who is precise and who is at fault? Such a problem is best answered with coherence.
The Bible is a taint
ed book transliterated from Aramaic
(several editions in print) to a multitude of languages. Furthermore, scribe
s had a tendency to distort
the Bible either through lack of knowledge or through intentional fraud
. That being said, Muslims only corroborate
parts of the Bible apparently in direct parallel with Quran.
Quran regularly contain summarized biblical stories in poetic graceful form. Condensed story of the sacrifice is recorded in Quran
beginning from Safat
(ranks) 37:100 and ending at 37:111. However, nowhere in these verses do we see an explicit statement calling for Abraham to sacrifice Ishmael by name. Nonetheless, it can be implicitly reasoned it was Ishmael to be sacrificed because after sacrifice event, Quran continue afterward in 37:112 and 37:113 that Allah
promised to offer Isaac
as a second son to Abraham.
Bible has a longer story to offer as per Genesis
. Only essential points will be extracted from Genesis for scrutiny
. Abraham was 75 when he arrived in Cannan
.(1) Abraham was married to his half sister Sarah
.(2) Abraham is 10 years older than Sarah.(3) Sarah can not bear children. As a result, she gave her handmaid Hagar
as a wife to Abraham.(4) Hagar became pregnant when Abraham was 86. Hagar was twice driven away by Sarah, before the child was born and after the child was born.(5) Abraham took his only son to be sacrificed.(6) Isaac was born when Abraham was 100 and Sarah 90.(7)
The biblical statement, "take your son, your only son Isaac." is paradoxical. According to both Genesis and Safat, Isaac was not born yet when Abraham took his only son to sacrifice. It is possible that Isaac was inserted in place of Ishmael. It is also possible that Isaac was added after your only son. There are abundant justifications offered by Jews and Christians to the illogical statement, "take your son your only son Isaac." None of these validations are strong enough or relate to each other to support this illogical statement.
Today, without a doubt in their mind, Muslims celebrate Eid Al Udha
(festival of sacrifice) in remembrance of Abraham near sacrifice to Ishmael. Moreover, it has caused a spin in recent time between the three religions on who rightfully own the land of Canan.
1 Genesis (12:11-16)
2 Genesis (20:12)
3 Genesis (17:17)
4 Genesis (16:3)
5 Genesis (16:4-12) Genesis (21:9-20)
6 Genesis (22:2-12)