Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

partial-birth abortion

created by Saige

(thing) by Saige (1.2 y) (print)   ?   1 C! I like it! Thu Apr 20 2000 at 20:46:51

A term that has been passed around by pro-life groups and politicians as something that needs to be banned, and often mentioned when talking about how bad abortion is.

The facts are never really adequately explained. The procedure is pretty bad, involving the killing of a third-trimester fetus. However, it is not done on a whim, only when medically necessary. It may be due to genetic defect in the fetus, major problems with the womb and/or birth canal, or similar things. For it to be done requires that it be impossible to deliver the baby, because of the dangers involved with this procedure.

Anyone who suggests this can be done on a woman who just doesn't want to have the child is incorrect.


(thing) by Uberfetus (4.2 y) (print)   ?   1 C! I like it! Thu Aug 10 2000 at 2:18:06

Well, this one's clear enough if you talk with science instead of rhetoric...

Partial-birth abortion is known within the medical community as "dilation and extraction", or "D&X". I've seen it mistakenly called "dilation and evacuation" as well. See Abortion Methods for the juicy details.

Saige is incorrect when she states that "the procedure is pretty bad, involving the killing of a third-trimester fetus." In reality, most D&X abortions are performed in the middle or end of the second trimester. Because of its relative simplicity and high success rate when compared to other methods, it is, for a few doctors, the preferred means of abortion.

Although most third-trimester D&X abortions are for medical reasons, the majority of second-trimester partial-births (and at the very least 30% of all D&X procedures) are performed for elective reasons. Since nationwide stats are not kept, this is only what those within the abortion community have reluctantly admitted, suggesting that the percentage of elective D&X is actually quite higher.

In addition, the most common health reason given is "depression". I, Uberfetus, receive treatment for that particular malady and do not understand which symptoms of depression preclude giving birth.

Most intriguing of all, the American Medical Association's official stance is that the procedure is never medically necessary and should be banned. This seems to be the opposite of Saige's claim. Personally, I feel that the AMA (the nation's most prestigous coalition of medical professionals) has more expertise on this matter than our own M-noder, but that's just my opinion.


"In the vast majority of cases, the procedure is performed on a healthy mother with a healthy fetus that is 20 weeks or more along. The abortion-rights folks know it, the anti-abortion folks know it, and so, probably, does everyone else."

-Ron Fitzsimmons
Executive Director for the National Coalition of Abortion Providers
The New York Times, February 26, 1997


printable version
chaos

Abortion methods post-birth abortion Why I sometimes consider suicide anti-abortion but pro-choice
The plural of anecdote is not data abortion American Medical Association The Princess Bride
M-noder Easy CD Creator Stalking horse Involuntary euthanasia
drug cycle George W. Bush's acceptance speech for the Republican Party presidential nomination womb incorrect
pro-life A fetus is a parasite Hate the sin, love the sinner pro-choice
zealot Evidence Anecdote No Compromises
Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help

Cool Staff Picks
What you are reading:
The soul gets growing pains, too
January 4, 2005
The Art of Bitchcraft
Kids from the short bus
The Dropa Disks
A Thousand Points of Light
Webster 1913 is a fake
J.S.G. Boggs
Brace Yourself
Flags and flag etiquette
Words that don't mean the same as they used to
An E2 Quest for the Middle East!
Rasputin : A hard man to kill
New Writeups
aneurin
Hilary Armstrong(person)
giantcactus
The Power of Electricity(personal)
TheLady
Eggs and tomatoes(recipe)
TheLady
Don't get me wrong - I'm a feminist(essay)
Scaevola
Scissors murder(person)
Yakushin
Green Chile Pecan, Red Chile Apple Pies(recipe)
TenMinJoe
BookMooch(idea)
Yakushin
Merlin(review)
Apatrix
Editor Log: May 2008(log)
Apatrix
Eggs and tomatoes(recipe)
locke baron
Sverdlov class cruiser(thing)
arcanamundi
IN THE GRIM FUTURE OF HELLO KITTY, THERE IS ONLY WAR.(fiction)
Glowing Fish
Northern Effect(idea)
Jet-Poop
Why I love Everything2(essay)
Rancid_Pickle
Old Scrotch Xmas(fiction)
Everything 2 is brought to you by the letter C and The Everything Development Company