Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

gift exchange

created by mblase

(thing) by mblase (1 mon) (print)   ?   (I like it!) Fri Nov 24 2000 at 21:42:04

A peculiarity unique to the Western world among those who celebrate Christmas (or the annual winter gift-giving holiday of your choice). A group of people -- family members, classmates, co-workers, etc. -- throw their names into a hat, then draw out the name of another person, and give a gift worth up to X amount of money to that person. The idea is that everyone in the group gets one gift from someone else, so no one feels left out of the holiday celebration.

Something in my spleen really dislikes this whole approach to the holiday, because it undermines my whole idea of what a gift is. I like to give people things for the holidays because they mean something special to me, and because I have a little extra good fortune in my bank account which I'd like to share with them. I don't do it just because I happen to be related to them, or work next to them. It's a choice to give something I have. It's personal.

I understand the practical and economical motives behind a gift exchange, especially where a large family is involved. I understand that it helps keep people who don't have a lot of money to give gifts with from comparing themselves to those who do. This is is good and noble, but it still feels wrong somehow.

If someone can't buy me a gift because they can't afford to, then I'm certainly not going to hold a club of guilt over their head for it. If someone can and does, I'm going to be grateful and appreciative, but I'm not going to feel like any guilt is being held over my head to return the gift, because I may not be able to afford it either.

The problem, I think, is in the strange idea that gifts need to be exchanged. I give you something, you give me something, that way everyone is still equal. But if you celebrate your holiday that way, doesn't it undermine the whole idea of giving something? Why not share your good financial fortune with those you love without expecting anything in return? Why not accept those gifts from others who have something to give, and just feel grateful rather than obligated?

I, personally, would rather receive one Christmas card cheerfully given than ten gifts given out of a sense of obligation. I would rather give ten small presents to those I care for most than one large gift to the one person whose name I drew. Cliches notwithstanding, it's not the size or quantity of the gifts, but the thought that went into them, that truly counts.


printable version
chaos

The Most Embarrassing Christmas Present Giving gifts Making a kickass lighter The Nightmare Before Christmas
Kriss Kringle What a rotten thing to do Yes Selling your Christmas presents on eBay
Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help

Cool Staff Picks
Look at this mess the Death Borg made!
Toaster
Penises have higher bandwidth than cable modems
geomorphology
The Texas Chain Saw Massacre
Automat
Writing and publishing
dual of a vector space
Everything Quests: Support Your Local Library
Making the Movies
John McCain
1965
The Wind That Shakes The Barley
Philosophus Stone Against the Cult of Terror!
New Writeups
Clarke
Multiculturalism(idea)
aneurin
Earl of Landaff(person)
Heitah
Pseudocide(idea)
XWiz
Google Knol(lede)
Mythi
July 24, 2008(personal)
locke baron
The fall of Earth(fiction)
BookReader
Fear the Cold(dream)
Pavlovna
Kathleen MacInnes(person)
stainedglass
1(fiction)
kalen
Three "T"s(idea)
octillion369
Undead(idea)
archiewood
Ico(fiction)
Heisenberg
Why I love Everything2(log)
octillion369
Death Knight(person)
XWiz
Are you hoping for a miracle?(review)
E2 is a by-product of the existence of The Everything Development Company