Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

Tibetan prayer wheel

created by Gritchka

(idea) by Gritchka (2.5 y) (print)   ?   (I like it!) 3 C!s Fri Jul 20 2001 at 16:41:34

In Tibetan Buddhism, a small wheel in which a paper prayer is inserted, so by turning the wheel the prayer may be repeated indefinitely. They are powered either by hand or by placement in the wind, supposedly.

In philosophy, a jocular term for an argument which is supposed by its believers to be doing something very profound, but which to others appears to be going round and round forever doing nothing.

The classic example is "Ah, but what is it really?", often accompanied by a smug sense of communing in a deeper spiritual plane than the poor jobbing philosopher or scientist who has nothing to offer but an explanation.

To attempt deeper understanding, greater generality, a more unified or objective approach, these are all laudable goals in discussion. The Tibetan prayer wheel however is something that does not engage with the argument. It does not propose a better alternative, or a more insightful or more complicated or more simple perspective, one which can be compared to the original thought: it simply repeats itself regardless of the original thought.

An attempt to answer it, that is to treat it as if it was a valid question, will come up with another answer, another explanation. But whatever this is, you can attach a 'really' to it and doubt whether that's what it really is.

This is just a verbal trick. To make noises with your mouth is not to make language. To string words together grammatically is not to speak sense. To utter an interrogative sentence is not (necessarily) to ask a question. And to ask a question is not to ask a sensible question, one that has an answer. If a question can not be answered it may be that (i) the answer is not yet known; (ii) the answer in the nature of things is unknowable; or (iii) the question is nonsense. The "Tibetan prayer wheel" is nonsense that has the spurious effect of sounding like insight.

A related fallacy is the No True Scotsman ploy.


printable version
chaos

No True Scotsman No Noders in Bhutan? Import some! An E2 Gathering and frequent flier mile grab Black Mass Joan of Arc on the 8:00 D5
The knight at the nexus of memory SE Powell Blvd undetectable illusion you can't prove that
prayer flag The Pundits 23 Days in Bhutan katak
Meeting the Dalai Lama spurious wheel of reincarnation She is like an onion
Mongolian Death Worm Hopper window armchair philosopher 1000 Hours Deluxe American Superwar Gold!
Old Growth Forests, 13th Century Temples, and Rites of Spring spammer praying machine Alex Grey
Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help

Cool Staff Picks
After stirring Everything, these nodes rose to the top:
incarnadine
The Wild Bunch
Mean Streets
Burning of the Libraries of Alexandria
Clinical depression
How to buy drugs in an open-air market
Welcome to the Involuntary Agnostics Association
An example of Atari 2600 source code
unique
Solar sail
the cool silence that inevitably follows the vanishing of aeroplanes
Wesley Willis
The erotic tales of 'old McMurty': that weird kid's favourite dead dog
New Writeups
SwimmingMonkey
Conversations with Fo Fo- the Loneliest dog in Purgatory(fiction)
locke baron
lynx(thing)
Simulacron3
Reality, Dimensions and the Natural Ontology(essay)
SubSane
Making Love to a 9-Foot Woman(person)
Ouzo
Thoughts(idea)
antigravpussy
I fall silent, listening. The breadcrumbs are talking about us(person)
calgon
Buffalo Bill by the pool(poetry)
gate
Anarchy is Order(idea)
ushdfgakjasgh
Scribeling(thing)
XWiz
Trism(review)
artman2003
Briefcase Full of Souls - Part I(fiction)
Dreamvirus
Alan Ladd(person)
waverider37
Harold Holt(person)
The Debutante
Until death do us part(fiction)
Ysardo
a brother to a sister(personal)
This page courtesy of The Everything Development Company