Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

The customs of your tribe are not laws of nature

created by skid

(idea) by skid (8.6 mon) (print)   ?   1 C! I like it! Fri Jun 09 2000 at 4:52:54

Originally said by characters in a play by George Bernard Shaw, it is an extremely true statement.

The idea that, on some level, you and only you are right is common to many people. Even by telling someone else that they are not right only reenforces the belief that you are right.

It's not just one nation, as obliquely referenced in the universal culture writeup; the only difference is how many you irritate by insisting you are right.... and I'm no better than the rest. I'm writing this node, aren't I?

This is the sort of thought that requires doublethink to live with; most people continue insisting they are right, but with the caveat that really, underneath it all, they know they're as full of shit as anyone else. Perhaps an enlightened few actually believe it.

Can you tell I can't get to sleep?


(idea) by Noung (1.8 min) (print)   ?   1 C! I like it! Mon Dec 10 2007 at 15:16:38

The realization that this statement is true constitutes the beginning of philosophy understood as the quest to discover what Being is, and in a political sense it is the starting point of the quest for natural law. The first man to realize this, whoever he was, was truly the first philosopher.

The factuality of this statement is inherent in the plurality of tribes and their different customs, which immediately demotes one's own customs from their privileged place so far as nature is concerned; anyone who is aware of this plurality cannot, in intellectual honesty, continue to believe that the customs of their tribe are laws of nature. Yet the customs of tribes have an important human role to play in binding a people together and ensuring their continuity throughout time: this is why the philosopher, in questioning the wisdom of the tribal elders, has always been seen as a threat. This was the basic reason for the execution of Socrates by the Athenians.

The Socratic method is based on enquiring into subjects by first establishing what the customs of various tribes say about something, and then comparing these customs and questioning their consistency so that something like truth might be approached. This was a sure guard against chauvinism, but also obviously a threat to the particular customs of the tribe which Socrates inhabited.

But what this enquiry into truth presupposes is the existence of customs which might be compared, as they are the starting point for analysis. It in fact thrives on the plurality of customs, something which the homogenizing effect of modernity has denied us in the modern age; the general decline of faith in our unique values may have destroyed our chauvinism, but it has not led us to truth, but rather to an intellectual abyss.

BrevityQuest07


printable version
chaos

Blue Eye / Brown Eye experiment universal culture Do Orthodox Jewish lesbian couples practice "family purity"? Keeping cereal in the refrigerator
Killing A Vampire: A Cross-Cultural Survey of Methodology If we define things as unreal, they may still be real in their consequences Atrocities in the Bible doublethink
I can't get published, but this crap can George Bernard Shaw Why can't they get out of The Matrix on cellular phones? The plural of anecdote is not data
What the hell is wrong with society today? The long-necked women of the Paduang tribe It is the way of my people You can't tell sleep where to go
When science questions itself (a rant) Hair-related legislation through the ages If we define things as real, they are real in their consequences Blithering idiot
Lesbian invisibility in language cultural osmosis O God of Earth and Altar Different Country, Different Morals
Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help


cooled by Deborah909

Cool Staff Picks
Nodes to live by:
Bolshevik
Lesbia
Bantustan
Termination dust
Why the Bible sucks
Playfair Cipher
I miss you, damn you for being so damn amazing
You noders still fucking suck, but your needing my wisdoms bad
Everything Quests - Classical Music
Fight Club as an extension of the Beat Generation
Jessica Lynch
Constitution of South Africa
Was the Allied Bombing in WW2 a success?
New Writeups
Adaptive Child
Roulade of Herbed Lamb with Stewed Garlic(recipe)
Choked Chicken
Friends who fuck(event)
StrawberryFrog
fair go(idea)
cesium
Long Day(thing)
Scaevola
Afrikaans insults(idea)
TheDeadGuy
Kissing your sister(dream)
ignis_glaciesque
Stagger Lee(person)
Rai Tai
Adventures in veterinary school: Year One(event)
The Custodian
ram accelerator(thing)
aneurin
Sparrow-mumbling(idea)
calgon
catbox poetry(poetry)
Scaevola
Roman class system(thing)
Meldon
Chicken stuffed with avocado and havarti(recipe)
Scientist
Fortitude Valley(place)
StrawberryFrog
Discrete(idea)
E2 is a by-product of the existence of The Everything Development Company