Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

The Concept of Mind

created by Gritchka

(thing) by Gritchka (2.5 y) (print)   ?   (I like it!) 2 C!s Tue May 08 2001 at 22:44:44

A book by the philosopher Gilbert Ryle, published in 1949, attacking the cartesian dogma of a mind separate from the body.

The book is one of the central planks of the analytic philosophy approach, and was hugely influential. Before it, the idea that minds were separate from brains and bodies was effectively the "official doctrine" as Ryle termed it. After it, it was difficult for any serious philosopher to maintain that the mind existed as a different kind of thing, as proposed by René Descartes.

Ryle coined the deliberately abusive expression "Ghost in the Machine" to caricature the prevailing doctrine. Another likeness he used was of a horse in the locomotive. He said that the prevailing doctrine held that the ordinary visible, physical behaviour of a human being was not enough to explain our thoughts, feelings, and other such mental activity, and that therefore there must be some private inner realm, a "mind", that sat inside the person and observed what the sensory data brought in. But the mind was supposed to be different from the merely physical receiver of sensation.

The recurring theme of Ryle's attack on this dogma is that it is a category mistake. It confuses entirely different kinds of things. Over and over again he offers examples such as this: when I write a node carefully, I am only doing one thing. I am not (a) writing a node, and (b) being careful. The care I exercise isn't an additional, separate, superadded activity, looking over the primary activity of the node-writing. They are one and the same things. To regard them as two activities is to make the mistake of calling "being careful" a kind of activity I do, on a par with, or in the same category as, the activity of writing.

He demonstrates that a huge range of things we "do" in the mental sense (concentrating, understanding, judging, supposing, expecting, etc. etc.) are not things we do, but rather they are ways we do things such as playing card-games, teaching children, practising for tests, solving crossword-puzzles, and so on. These latter are overt behavioural acts, and the mental component is part of how we do them. It is not a distinct mental "action". So no distinct agent, a "mind", is required to account for them.


printable version
chaos

The Very Model of an Eliminative Materialist Gilbert Ryle category mistake Ghost in the Machine
Theory of Mind Theory of everything Consciousness Explained Cartesian
mind qualia mindlessness Logical behaviourism
Consciousness If you could read my mind Greek Dark Age quale
eliminativist mushin Epicurus Francesca Fiore
door Steak Sensation disposition
Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help

Cool Staff Picks
Little presents from the Node Fairy:
Questions to ask yourself on the way to self discovery
Anti-coffee legislation throughout history
Skunk Cabbage
Do you remember how small your body was when you were five?
How to transmit information faster than light speed
The Feynman Lectures on Physics
You too can spend four years
Hammond organ
Lawrence Textile Strike
lullaby
Tortoise
Dem Bones
schrebers testimony
New Writeups
Heitah
Why I love Everything2(person)
trixingee
Dungeon Mastering for the first time(idea)
Netrat0
It's Called Subtext, Honey(person)
eyeofthebeholder
The Dragon(idea)
Heitah
consist, comprise, constitute, or compose(idea)
Meezzio
Gotlandssnus(thing)
argv
Astral Plane(idea)
Madara
One Winged Angel(fiction)
Tom Rook
Talk is cheap(poetry)
shaogo
Adelle Davis(person)
Aerobe
race car g sfjsgsd(poetry)
Binah
Dream Log: July 5, 2008(dream)
StrawberryFrog
Forgotten things in space(idea)
antigravpussy
velvet revolution fairy tale(idea)
Heitah
Nerve agent VX(thing)
This page courtesy of The Everything Development Company