Or, as a third option, maybe the path of events is determined by the laws of nature, in which everything has only one corse to follow. A hypothetical all-knowing being would be able to tell what would happen next, but could not change it-- even if such a being existed.
Numbers 2, 3, and 4 still hold.
While destiny is driven to acheive an end, this other type of unfree will is is driven from a begining... Or not. But driven from a past, at the very least. I'm not sure what you'd call it. Determinism or fate, maybe.
Or, as a fourth option, maybe there's a lot more randomness in the universe than we like to think -- and not just coin flipping randomness (after all,that's little more than rocket science), but complete, unpredictible randomness. Given a complete description of everything in the universe, and every force acting upon those things, and all the rules governing these, maybe a calculation of the future must still be indeterminate, because some things happen without any cause.
See The problem of freewill. |