Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

Correlation is not causation

created by Wintersweet

(idea) by Wintersweet (1.1 y) (print)   ?   I like it! Sun Apr 02 2000 at 2:19:09

Just because two phenomena are associated, one does not necessarily cause the other. A frequent reasoning fallacy exploited by partisans of about any cause.

(idea) by bitter_engineer (6.3 y) (print)   ?   2 C!s I like it! Mon May 22 2000 at 23:51:03

Very important to remember when applying any sort of social science, such as psychology.

Both my high school and college psych courses provided me with the 'ice cream causes drowning' example:

Drowning deaths are most frequent during the months when ice cream sales are at their peak.

From this fact alone, one can make the causality go two ways:
  1. By eating ice cream, you are more likely to get a cramp and drown while swimming.
  2. When people drown, the mourners are more likely to console themselves by going out for ice cream.
Both of these theories are pretty shaky. What is more likely is that we did not look at enough information:

3. During the summer, more people are likely to go swimming, and drown. People are also more likely to buy ice cream.

In this model, note that drowning and ice cream sales do not effect each other, but both are effected by a common cause.


(idea) by Gorgonzola (1.5 hr) (print)   ?   I like it! Tue Dec 26 2000 at 1:57:30

Another example, from an early statistics class of mine:

The number of arrests for prostitution in a given year in Sydney correlate strongly with the number of graduates from Harvard Business School that year.

Make what you want of that. Whatever you make of it, you will be wrong.

printable version
chaos

Coincidental Correlation The plural of anecdote is not data Student caught with loaded .38 cum hoc ergo propter hoc
I was promised flying cars Freakonomics Logically flawed anti-drug commercials post hoc ergo propter hoc
Want to be shot in the US or beaten in the UK? Geek Teen Magazine Quiz Grisham vs. Stone on movie violence Hot water freezes faster than cold water
Power Kill daytime running lights affect vs. effect The growing problem of cultural illiteracy
To understand, predict, and control human behavior Electronic Devices Run on Smoke Forty acres and a mule Crow Augury
fallacy cycle of causation older brother effect novus actus interveniens
Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help

Cool Staff Picks
Drink up!
Danzayémon, Chief of the Etas
eternal recurrence
HIV test
November 30, 2006
What's with all the "nodegel" stuff?
Love is not an emotion
Unbleached flour
The Satanic Verses
Solar sail
Windows 1.x
Freedom of religion is not freedom from religion
Capitalize, please
Living and dealing with depression
New Writeups
Dimview
Genie, meanie, miny, mo(fiction)
FrankThomas
existence proof(thing)
ChimbleySweep
Reverse ferret(thing)
Ysardo
Why I love Everything2(idea)
Apatrix
Boys Don't Cry(review)
locke baron
Kashin class destroyer(thing)
Rancid_Pickle
Wergle Flomp entry: "With Certainty"(poetry)
arcanamundi
Philadelphia Latin and Greek Institute(person)
minnow
Shotshell(thing)
graceness
What says the sea, little shell?(personal)
zoeb
protection(review)
sekicho
common seal(idea)
aneurin
The Smiley Face Murders(event)
minnow
shotgun shot sizes(thing)
rack and ruin
For Professor Sweeney: London Ad Lucem(idea)
Everything 2 is brought to you by the letter C and The Everything Development Company