Everything2
Near Matches
Ignore Exact
Full Text
Everything2

Coincidental Correlation

created by anomie

(idea) by anomie (6.1 y) (print)   ?   (I like it!) 1 C! Mon May 22 2000 at 22:52:29

A logical fallacy in which it is assumed that because one thing happened after another, the first caused the second. Also known as post hoc ergo propter hoc. The problem here is that correlation does not equal causation.

Example: "I walked under a ladder, and two minutes later a meteorite hit my car! So walking under a ladder is bad luck!"

To prove the fallacy, show that the correlation is coincidental. Showing that either the effect would have occurred even without the cause or the effect was caused by something else is a good way to go about this.


If it were "I walked under a ladder and got hit in the head by a paint can", the walking under the ladder may in fact have caused the paint can to fall on your head. But it's still not bad luck.

(idea) by bitter_engineer (6.4 y) (print)   ?   (I like it!) 2 C!s Mon May 22 2000 at 23:25:46

B.F. Skinner did a cool little experiment that demonstrated Coincidental Correlation. He set up a food pellet dispenser to dispense food at random intervals. He put a pigeon in a box with said dispenser.

After a while, the pigeon trained itself to perform unnatural acts like hopping on one leg and tucking its head under its wing in the hopes of getting a treat, because by coincidence, a pellet had been dispensed the last couple of times it had done that.

This is what Skinner called superstition. I think of this experiment every time I hear someone resort to Coincidental Correlation.


printable version
chaos

post hoc ergo propter hoc cum hoc ergo propter hoc Ten reasons to believe in God B.F. Skinner
The Fez is Responsible for Global Warming If the government wasn't involved in the Sept 11 attacks, what was it doing? Daisy Fuentes does not come with that six-pack of Miller Lite Correlation is not causation
roving herds of dangerous cars Superstition Crow Augury correlation
Joint Effect autoerotic depontication inflection Bravo
ballroom dance Diet Coke David Hume on Causality effect
Coincidental Cause experiment
Y'know, if you log in, you can write something here, or contact authors directly on the site. Create a New User if you don't already have an account.
  Epicenter
Login
Password

password reminder
register

Everything2 Help


cooled by Tem42

Cool Staff Picks
The best nodes of all time:
'Ayin
The Joy Luck Fight Club
If someone wants to do something and it isn't hurting you... DON'T BE A FUCKING DICK
Loving is the ocean, kissing is the wet sand
public executions
Dog's egg
Religious dietary laws and restraints
Australia
Hydra
Under Orders
X-Men: The Last Stand
Morrowind
Telegard
New Writeups
doctor wilson
Soup, of the green variety(recipe)
Ctrl Y
cognitive dissonance(fiction)
SharQ
Gone Baby Gone(review)
halfWit
If I could, I'd title this "Freedom"(thing)
Roninspoon
Airline Hero(thing)
Ktistec
Why Women Are Always Cold(person)
doctor wilson
Drug policy reform(thing)
tejasa
Easy Raspberry Cheesecake(recipe)
Joysim
Drug policy reform(idea)
aneurin
Tyburn(place)
niruena
Boiling to death(idea)
artman2003
summer(thing)
doctor wilson
The Silver City and the Silent Sea(log)
Dreamvirus
The Silver City and the Silent Sea(poetry)
Aerobe
A nihilist's soulmate(poetry)
E2 is a by-product of the existence of The Everything Development Company